HangupsMusic.com – In a revealing moment of introspection, pop icon Justin Timberlake recently pulled back the curtain on his monumental catalog, pinpointing one particular track as the zenith of his storied career. During a candid conversation with Complex on Thursday, November 5, Timberlake embarked on the challenging task of ranking his own extensive discography, ultimately settling on the Timbaland and Danja co-produced masterpiece, "What Goes Around…Comes Around," which famously ascended to the pinnacle of the Billboard Hot 100 in March 2007. This choice, coming from an artist with an unparalleled track record of chart-topping success, offers a unique perspective on the song’s enduring resonance and personal significance.
Timberlake, a veritable hitmaker with an impressive 39 solo entries on the Billboard Hot 100 and an additional 13 as a pivotal member of the legendary NSYNC, possesses a career defined by innovation and sustained impact. His decision to elevate "What Goes Around…Comes Around" above a slew of other iconic tracks speaks volumes about its unique place in his artistic journey. "I would put this at No. 1 or No. 2," he confided during the interview, highlighting the track’s immediate and profound connection to his creative process. He further elaborated that it was the inaugural composition penned for his groundbreaking 2006 album, FutureSex/LoveSounds*, an LP that redefined the sound of pop and R&B for a generation.
Beyond its musical brilliance, Timberlake took the opportunity to finally address and clarify a long-standing rumor surrounding the song’s genesis. "Maybe I should dispel a rumor at this point, which has gone around forever, which it’s not a personal story of mine; it’s actually a personal story from a friend," he revealed. This clarification sheds new light on the track’s narrative, a tale of infidelity and karmic retribution that many had speculated was drawn from Timberlake’s own romantic experiences. Instead, it emerged from a deeply personal conversation with a close confidant who was navigating a tumultuous relationship.
Recalling the poignant moment of inspiration, Timberlake recounted his friend’s raw honesty: "He was going through it and telling me what had happened." Recognizing the powerful emotional current, Timberlake sought permission to transform the real-life drama into song. "I said, ‘Do you mind if I write about this?’ And I quote, my friend said, ‘Yeah, torch that b***h. What goes around comes around.’ I was like, ‘I have to go. Thank you, I have to go.’" This electrifying exchange underscores the organic, almost urgent, nature of the song’s creation, capturing a moment of raw human emotion and universal truth.
Indeed, the long-held speculation that "What Goes Around…Comes Around" drew its narrative from the fractured relationship between Timberlake’s close friend Juan "Trace" Ayala and The Girl Next Door actress Elisha Cuthbert gains significant credence with Timberlake’s recent admission. While not explicitly confirming the individuals, his description of the friend’s story aligns perfectly with the widely circulated rumor. The song’s ability to tap into themes of betrayal, consequence, and the cyclical nature of justice resonated profoundly with listeners, irrespective of the specific identities involved. It became an anthem for those who believed in karmic retribution, delivered with Timberlake’s signature blend of vulnerability and sophisticated swagger.

Remarkably, the composition itself materialized with astonishing speed. "I just went in and again, this song was written in damn near 20 minutes," Timberlake recounted, illustrating a moment of pure creative flow where melody, lyrics, and emotion converged effortlessly. He emphasized that the song’s impact extends beyond its auditory components, noting the integral role of its accompanying visual narrative. "It was just flowing. The interlude that goes with it and then you put the video with it," he added, referencing the iconic, nearly 10-minute-long cinematic music video starring Scarlett Johansson. The video, a mini-movie in itself, amplified the song’s dramatic tension and emotional depth, creating a multi-sensory experience that cemented its place in pop culture. "This just hit on all cylinders for me," Timberlake concluded, perfectly encapsulating the holistic brilliance of the entire package.
The decision to crown "What Goes Around…Comes Around" meant it edged out a formidable lineup of other career-defining tracks that rounded out his personal top five. Among the contenders were the epic ballad "Mirrors," the infectious club anthem "My Love," the daring and innovative "SexyBack," and the emotionally charged "Cry Me a River." Each of these songs represents a significant milestone in Timberlake’s career, showcasing his versatility and willingness to push musical boundaries.
"Cry Me a River," released in 2002, was a pivotal post-NSYNC statement, a dark and brooding R&B track that boldly announced his solo artistic direction, largely defined by its evocative lyrics and groundbreaking production. "SexyBack," the lead single from FutureSex/LoveSounds, was a seismic shift, an electro-pop behemoth that dared to be different and instantly became a cultural phenomenon. "My Love," another Timbaland collaboration from the same album, showcased intricate production and Timberlake’s smooth, effortless vocals, earning widespread critical acclaim and chart success. "Mirrors," from 2013’s The 20/20 Experience*, offered a more mature, heartfelt reflection on enduring love, a sprawling, eight-minute ode to his wife Jessica Biel that demonstrated his evolving emotional depth as a songwriter. Yet, despite the immense weight and impact of these other masterpieces, "What Goes Around…Comes Around" held a unique and unparalleled position in Timberlake’s artistic heart.
Beyond his own catalog reflections, Timberlake also offered an intriguing anecdote about his influence on fellow artists. He recounted a conversation with Ye (formerly Kanye West), who revealed that Timberlake’s genre-bending hit "SexyBack" served as a direct inspiration for his own colossal track, "Stronger." This cross-pollination of creative energy saw West bring in Timbaland, a frequent collaborator of Timberlake, to meticulously craft the percussive backbone of his Graduation smash, underscoring the profound impact of Timberlake’s innovative sound on the broader music landscape. "You could probably find it, Kanye came to one of the shows on the FutureSex/LoveShow Tour. I had him come up and we did ‘Stronger’ together," JT fondly recalled, highlighting a memorable live collaboration that cemented their mutual respect. "He showed up and was suited up like I was. It was a moment. I remember talking a lot about that song."
Looking ahead, Timberlake also teased exciting new collaborations, revealing that he recently hit the studio with acclaimed rapper Don Toliver. This unexpected pairing came about after Timberlake made a surprise appearance at Toliver’s Miami tour stop in August. The connection isn’t entirely new; Toliver famously sampled Timberlake’s classic "Rock Your Body" on his OCTANE standout "BODY." The impromptu studio session following the concert hints at intriguing new directions for Timberlake’s sound. "I was like, ‘Don’t you have a studio on the road?’ He was like, ‘Yeah.’ I was like, ‘Cool, take a shower. Let’s work.’ We stayed at the arena for a couple hours. We did a few ideas," Timberlake divulged, hinting at potential new music that could fuse his pop sensibilities with Toliver’s distinct trap-R&B style. This willingness to collaborate across genres demonstrates Timberlake’s enduring artistic curiosity and commitment to staying relevant in an ever-evolving musical landscape.
Justin Timberlake’s reflection on his extensive and celebrated catalog provides a rare and valuable insight into the mind of a generational artist. His designation of "What Goes Around…Comes Around" as the apex of his career speaks not only to its commercial success and critical acclaim but also to its profound personal resonance, a track born from a friend’s raw story and transformed into a universal anthem. From his indelible mark with NSYNC to his groundbreaking solo work and his continued exploration of new sounds and collaborations, Timberlake remains a dynamic force in music. His journey underscores the power of authentic storytelling, rapid creative bursts, and the synergistic magic of song, visual, and performance, all converging to create moments that truly hit "on all cylinders." Fans eager to delve deeper into Timberlake’s musical journey and hear more of his candid reflections can watch his full appearance on Complex*’s "Re-Rank" series.

